SHIP* files amended rehab plan, factoring in opt-out states, reduced benefit scenarios; Covid-19 dynamics impacting liabilities

Oct. 23, 2020 — Rehabilitators for the insolvent long term care insurer Senior Health Insurance Company of Pennsylvania filed an amended rehabilitation plan proposal Oct. 21 with the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania that addresses options for policyholders in states that want to opt out of the plan, the effect of Covid-19 and changes to calculations and the scope and availability of benefit reductions.

These changes are update the initial April 2020 filed rehabilitation plan. The plan is effective when the court okays it. So far, there are a number of intervenors and the process can be lengthy even as the company, founded in 1887 as the Home Beneficial Society, sees its financial condition deteriorate. Prior to the filing for rehabilitation in January 2020, it was licensed in 46 states, the District of Columbia and the U.S. Virgin islands. It has not sold new policies since 2003 and was once part of Conseco Senior Health Insurance Co.

The funding gap is expected to be $1.2 billion as of the effective date of rehabilitation. SHIP’s financial condition continues to decline, according to the new document. It is estimated that SHIP’s funding gap is more than $1 billion, up from $916 million at year-end 2019.

The rehab plan is an attempt to square up the insolvent company’s claims with its liabilities through a policyholder menu of premium increases and benefit reductions so it does not have to go into liquidation. The goal is to significantly reduce the funding gap, a scenario best advanced under a combination of options presented to policyholders that would increase premiums and/or reduce the rich benefits in their LTC policies to more affordable but more slender coverage.

The multi-phase plan is designed to provide policyholders what they would get, at a minimum, from state guaranty associations in the event of a liquidation.

If 100% of SHIP’s active and disabled policyholders choose two favored options during phase one of the rehabilitation, SHIP’s entire funding gap would be eliminated and the second phase wouldn’t be necessary, the rehabilitators said.

These options are roughly, keeping the current premium and downgrading benefits and taking basic policy endorsements at the so-called “if knew ” premium or the realistic cost if the actuaries who wrote the policies a few decades ago, or less, actually knew what the future held–longevity, lower interest rates, the endurance of chronic diseases and much higher cost of facility or home medical care.

The rehabilitation team, led by Pennsylvania Insurance Commissioner Jessica Altman and Special Deputy Rehabilitator Patrick Cantilo, looked at liquidation, according to the new document, but decided against it to instead offer policyholders additional choices to address their individual needs with the ability for current coverage to stay in place if they are willing and able to pay the much-higher premium rate increase.

The rehab team also looked at a “good bank-bad” bank scenario but found the process would be very complex and would require insurance licenses in the states, where most of those licenses have now been pulled.

In jurisdictions/states that will object to the proposed plan or opt-out, policyholders wouldn’t be permitted to select from th full menu of the plan’s options but still have choices, albeit with some policies downgraded to a lower benefit level. Some states have already filed to intervene in the proceedings.

Of interest is what SHIP is finding with respect to the virulent Covid-19 virus’s mortality and morbidity. Preliminary data indicates that COVID-19 might be causing a decrease in the number of claims filed, and, as expected, and an increase in the number of deaths among the aging population insured by SHIP.

The average SHIP LTC policyholder is 86 and the average claimant is 89 years-old, according to the document. Covid-19 mortality might “reduce slightly SHIP’s deficit,” the rehabilitator stated, but this effect could be temporary.

However, another feature of Covid-19 — the economy — is impacting the bottom line, too.

Many SHIP policyholders have delayed making their required premium payment, the document said, and while SHIP is allowing the delays per regulatory agencies to a degree, “these payments aggravate substantially SHIP’s financial difficulties.” The rehabilitator made clear this forgiveness of premium payments cannot go on forever, and will likely lead to an increased amount of terminations. In fact, there have already been a slight increase in such non-payment of premium terminations.

SHip’s policies and claimants are declining, as the amended document lays out. By June 30, 2020, SHIP had 42,559 of direct policies, of which 5,402 were on claim. Total of administered LTC policies was therefore 44,673, of which 5,753 were on claim.

At the end of 2019, SHIP had 45,518 of direct policies, with 5,776 on claim. SHIP was administering a total of 47,785 policies of which 6,152 were on claim.

The rehabilitators warned that generally, policyholders whose policies were issued in states that have not approved rate increases over preceding years will face higher premium increases or benefit reductions under the plan, to avoid cross-subsidization between and among states.

*SHIP is now known as SHIP in Rehabilitation, so is not an actual licensed insurer The National Organization of Life & Health Guaranty Associations notes that SHIP is obligated for the LTC policies of the following companies: • Transport Life Insurance Co. • American Travelers Life Insurance Co. • United General Life Insurance Co. • Continental Life Insurance Co. due to the fact they merged into or were acquired by the former Conseco.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s